Ireland / Court of Appeal / No. 186/12 / The People at the Suit of the Director of Public Prosecutions v. Anthony Elders
Country
Ireland
Title
Year
Decision/ruling/judgment date
Incident(s) concerned/related
Related Bias motivation
Groups affected
Court/Body type
Court/Body
Key facts of the case
This case relates to the previous conviction of an Irish man in the Circuit Court for criminal damage and assault on another man of perceived Asian descent following an argument among a number of people. In the course of the assault, racist language was used and the victim sustained lacerations to his face and damage to property. The case was an appeal brought by the appellant against the severity of a sentence of five years imprisonment for assault causing harm and criminal damage. The racist element was judged to be an aggravating factor. However, the Court of Appeal found that the sentencing court had failed to take appropriate account of the mitigating factors during sentencing.
Main reasoning/argumentation
The Court acknowledged that there had been a racist dimension to the attack and that this had been an aggravating factor. The Court acknowledged that this had been considered in the original trial based on the facts of the case.
Is the case related to the application of the Framework Decision on Racism and Xenophobia, the Racial Equality Directive?
Key issues (concepts, interpretations) clarified by the case
The issue of racism as an aggravating factor and its subsequent impact on sentencing has been acknowledged as factor for consideration.
Results (sanctions, outcome) and key consequences or implications of the case
The original conviction resulted in a sentence of five years imprisonment. While accepting the very serious nature of the offence, the Court of Appeal found that the sentencing court had failed to take appropriate account of the mitigating factors and suspended the final 12 months of the sentence, subject to an offer of €4000 compensation being paid to the injured party.
Key quotation in original language and its unofficial translation into English with reference details
“Among the very many aggravating factors present were that there was a racist dimension, an aspect that was very properly highlighted by the Circuit Court judge. It may be that as counsel for the appellant said that this was not the case where someone was attacked because of their race, but that there was a racist dimension is nonetheless clear and that is an aggravated fact”.